I’ve said before that when I get the same word from two disparate sources, I pay attention.
First, a preface: I’ve written about Artificial Intelligence (AI) negatively twice recently. Once was to note that some popular “singers,” both secular and Christian were completely AI generated. The other time was to caution against using AI as a life coach. But I have not participated in the gloom and doom talk that’s prevalent these days.
Both Seth Godin and Sahil Bloom spoke to that phenomenon a couple of days apart. First Seth. In his daily blog of March 4, he links to an interview he gave recently. I haven’t listened to all of it yet, but the opening grabbed me.
Responding to a prompt “Are you pro-AI?” Seth said something like this:
Let’s think about it like the weather. You can be pro-snow or anti-snow, but if it’s snowing out, it’s still snowing out.
I’m glad there are electric typewriters instead of manual typewriters. I’m glad there are spell checkers. Am I glad AI is going to cause disruption to people I care about and industries I care about? It doesn’t matter.
Let me interrupt here. Seth said his reaction to AI’s (possible) disruption doesn’t matter. Like snow (Seth lives in New York, and I’m sure snow was fresh on his mind.), AI is here whether we’re for it or against it. I think that falls under the category of why have opinions about something you can do nothing about? Seth continues:
Here is this tool…and I’m playing with it joyously. I’m aware that people can make arguments about it all day long. It’s just a waste of time. When photography came along, painters were furious. So were wedding photographers when the iPhone came along.
Again, it’s a waste of time to make arguments and say that AI technology is going to put people out of business. I notice we still appreciate artists and some folks still make their living photographing weddings. A few months ago someone writing in the Wall Street Journal pointed that out that a “You’d better believe it” prediction was made several years ago that AI would put radiologists out of business. A few years later we have more radiologists than ever.
Sahil Bloom, writing just three days after Seth’s March 4 blog said that his news feeds are blowing up with negative reports about AI. Why? Quite simply:
Negativity drives online news consumption.
Sahil cites research that claims, “For a headline of average length, each additional negative word increased the click-through rate by 2.3%.” Graphically:
Sahil’s piece is worth the read in its entirety. He opens the second part of his essay with:
So, yes, I feel like I need to say something about AI…And this may not be popular…I’m optimistic about the future. – Sahil Bloom, emphasis his
In other words,
Fret not!
The day I read Sahil Bloom’s optimism about AI, Christianity Today published an article by a professor who used AI to help him research Jesus’ teaching and miracle priorities. Seth Godin uses AI to do “tasks” so that he freer to create new content. Sahil Bloom closes with…
So, let’s all strive to be a bit more optimistic. Not blindly, but thoughtfully. By becoming aware of the overwhelming bias towards negativity. By making a concerted effort to balance your information diet…I don’t think there is any denying that the coming few decades will have periods of uncertainty. Jobs that felt safe may no longer be. Career paths we planned for will get shaken up. To paraphrase Mark Twain, a lot of things we know for sure probably just ain’t so. But despite all of that, you’ll make it through. – Sahil Bloom, emphasis his
Isaiah told us centuries ago:
For the LORD spoke thus to me with his strong hand upon me, and warned me not to walk in the way of this people, saying: “Do not call conspiracy all that this people calls conspiracy, and do not fear what they fear, nor be in dread. But the LORD of hosts, him you shall honor as holy. Let him be your fear, and let him be your dread. (Isaiah 8.11 – 13, ESV)


